Care for some “Shoo-Fly Pies”? And while you’re there, maybe grab some “Amish Stuff”….. you won’t find these items at McDonald’s. I suppose that is the saddest thing about the near extinction of roadside diners in America – you’ve replaced a beautiful variety with boring homogeny.
Once upon a time, American roads were dotted with individually owned diners offering a wonderful diversity of eating choices – nearly always proclaiming the food is “baked on premises”. Then two things happened which spelled the end: (1) the arrival of super cheap, super quick fast food franchises and (2) the arrival of interstate highways. The diners lined up along roads actually within the towns and provinces; whereas, the new breed of fast food conglomerated around interstate exits – often not tied to the towns at all.
Although, the friendly roadside diner is largely a thing of the past, we still have the pictures and postcards of their heyday. Here is a look at the tip of the iceberg, just a small sampling (13) of the many great roadside diners of yesteryear. (Note: I didn’t choose the most crazy and outlandish, but rather a sampling of the average, to get you in the zone of what they were really like, not just their extreme examples.) Enjoy.
Millburn Diner – Restaurant ‘ “Fine Continental & American Cuisine and Athenian Specialties. All baking done on premises. Owned & operated by Gus Thermenos Family” Open until 2 AM on weekends!
I’ll start with the Millburn Diner because it makes two important points. First, we shouldn’t think of all these diners as “greasy spoons” and “hash houses”- a lot of them had classy interiors and fine dining. Second, not all of these diners have gone belly-up. The Millburn looks a lot different today, but it’s still around. I’ll provide the addresses for some of these so that you can look them up on Google Maps – and, maybe just maybe, if they’re still around, you can pay them a visit if you’re in the neighborhood.
72 Essex St. & Lackawanna Pl., Millburn, NJ 07041 (Google Maps link)
“Zinn’s Modern Diner, U.S. Route 222 – Denver, Pennsylvania, Located in the Heart of the Penna. Dutch Section…. Specializing in the Finest Penna. Dutch Cooking and Baking. Open 24 Hours. Before you leave – visit our unique Penna. Dutch Gift Shop.”
I love how these diners often tried to lure travelers with big statues and bold signs. It was a bit garish, but it was part of the charm.
“Elmer Diner Home Style Cooking, Route 40, Harding Highway, Elmer, New Jersey. Slim & Anne McKenzie, Props.”
I’ll bet Slim McKenzie was one helluva cook.
“The Chief Diner, 2127 Main Ave., Durango, Colorado. This very unique Cafe, all hand painted by a famous Colored Artist, is made form one of the first Narrow Gauge Railroad Coaches to come over the D&RGWRR. It was used in the early eighties by Otto Mears on his once famous Rainbow Route from Silverton to Ironton, Colo. During the early days it was attacked by Indians and there were many arrow heads buried in the wood.”
Kids in the 1950s were Cowboy & Indian crazy – they would have begged their parents to stop here. How quaint that it was hand pained by a “colored artist”.
“Triangle Seafood and Steaks Restaurant, Highway 35 – Manasquan, N.J. Welcome aboard the S.S. Triangle! Serving delicious steaks and seafood fresh from the ocean only minutes away.
The owner seems so proud of his little buffet. Americans today require buffets long enough to make them sweaty and tired by the time they reach the end. But check out those lobsters – I’ll be the fresh seafood here was out of this world.
“Ideal Diner, 613 White Horse Pike, egg Harbor, N.J. – A famous diner town since 1918. Noted for fine food and fast, courteous service. Ideal stopping place to and from the seashore. 24 hour service.”
Sadly, there’s a McDonald’s right where the Ideal Diner used to be. Google Map link.
“When in the mood for better food Stop At The Shillington Diner – Restaurant, U.S. Route 222 – 3 miles from Reading Shillington, Pennsylvania. The Best in Pennsylvania Dutch Cooking. Served in Our Modern Coffee Shop and Beautiful Air-Conditioned For Your Comfort, and Spacious Parking Facilities.”
I love looking behind the counter at these old diners. This one has air-conditioning, so you know business was good.
“Century Restaurant, 31 S. Black Horse Pike, Runnemede, N.J., 08078. Serving breakfast, lunch and dinner. Baking on premises. Open 24 hours. It’s the quality that counts.”
Looking at the location on Google Maps, it seems the Century has been replaced by another diner -but it’s new, flashy and probably lacks the homely charm of the original. Also note that the picture above is from 1970. The Golden of Age of the Diner had to be the 1950s, but it was by no means over in 1970 – just on the slow decline.
“Bayway Diner & Restaurant, 663-655 Bayway Ave., Elizabeth, N.J. Air Conditioned – Excellent Food – Unsurpassed Service – An Atmosphere You’ll Like. Any item on our menu can be neatly packaged to take out in a special insulated box, and the food stays hot up to an hour.”
Man, the Bayway had take-out down to a science.
“Muller’s Diner-Restaurant & Pancake House. In the beautiful Eastern Poconos. U.S. Route 209, 7 miles north of Stroudsburg, Pa. Superb American & German Cuisine… specializing in Sauerbraten, Steaks, Chops and Fresh Sea Food. Famous for our home baked pies and old fashioned doughnuts. 21 varieties of pancakes and waffles.”
A perfect example of the beautiful variety I’m talking about. McDonald’s may offer 6-7 value meals, but you’re not going to find Sauerbraten and old fashioned doughnuts.
“Brownies Diner, 34250 Michigan avenue, Wayne Michigan.”
I was pleased to see Brownies still around (Google Maps link); although it looks like it’s seen better days. This is a fantastic shot of the chef’s domain.
“Glenn’s Diner in Historic Gettysburg. Featuring our home baked pies and pastries. Open 24 hours a day – Seating Capacity 166. 90 Buford Avenue, U.S. 30 West, Gettysburg, Pa. 17325”
According to Google Maps, this is now Dunlap’s Restaurant and Bakery. I’m sure it’s nice – at least it’s not a McDonald’s.
“Peter Pank Colonial Diner, Featuring Home Style Cooking. All pastry baked on premises – Seating capacity 117 – Air-conditioned – Ample parking space. WE SERVE WONDERFUL FOOD. Sayreville, N.J.”
Yes, I know there’s an vast overrepresentation of New Jersey and Pennsylvania diners in this post. The best diners of all lined The Mother Road (Route 66) which began in Chicago and ended in Santa Monica. Stay tuned for those. Until next next time, if you’re traveling in America, maybe think about stopping forgoing a McRib and stopping at place where “baking is done on premises”. Just a thought.
Would you like to support Flashbak?
Please consider making a donation to our site. We don't want to rely on ads to bring you the best of visual culture. You can also support us by signing up to our Mailing List. And you can also follow us on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter. For great art and culture delivered to your door, visit our shop.